Evidence Lead

Mommy I have Been Good Episode 2

Episode 2 · Angela, Dad, Hubert

Episode 2 recap

The father confronts the young girl about wandering off. Despite her attempts to explain, Hubert lies and claims he gave her instructions she failed to follow. The father believes Hubert and retrieves a wooden ruler. The girl remembers being locked away without food previously and offers her hand in fear. The father strikes her palm. He then demands she shout her promise to obey, leaving her sobbing as she tries to satisfy his demand.

Episodes

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Next episode

Mommy I have Been Good

Tap below to keep watching.

Continue watching

Opens in a new tab

Episode 2 scene by scene

  1. 00:00: Father confronts the girl

    The father stands in the living room and angrily scolds the young girl for wandering off. The girl cries while trying to tell him that she stayed where she was supposed to be, but he ignores her explanation.

  2. 00:11: Hubert lies about instructions

    Hubert enters the conversation and pretends to be helpful. He claims he told the girl exactly where to wait, but asserts that the driver simply could not find her. The father listens to Hubert's account of the situation.

  3. 00:18: Father prepares the punishment

    The father accepts Hubert's lie as the truth. He walks over to the sideboard to retrieve a wooden ruler. He then turns back to the girl and commands her to hold out her hand for the impending punishment.

  4. 00:27: The girl remembers starvation

    The girl recalls a past punishment where she was locked in her room without food. She remembers the experience of starving until she eventually lost consciousness, which increases her fear of the father’s current anger in the room.

  5. 00:40: The father strikes her

    Terrified of being locked away again, the girl holds out her palm. The father swings the wooden ruler and hits her hand hard. She reacts with physical pain and fear as the father continues his harsh disciplinary actions.

  6. 00:46: Demanding a louder response

    The father asks if she will remember to stop wandering off. When she replies quietly, he yells at her to speak with more volume. She sobs uncontrollably while forced to shout her compliance to appease his demands.

Key lines from episode 2

“Didn't I tell you not to wander off and to stay close to your brothers?”

Father · The father confronts the girl in the living room regarding her behavior yesterday.

“I told her to wait right there yesterday, but the driver didn't see her there, right?”

Hubert · Hubert manipulates the situation by lying to his father about the girl's actions.

“Give me your hand.”

Father · The father demands the girl submit to punishment with the wooden ruler.

“Don't wander off again. Will you remember that next time?”

Father · The father questions the girl after striking her hand with the ruler.

“Y-yes, I remember.”

Young girl · The girl tearfully answers her father after being forced to speak louder.

How episode 2 ends

The girl sobs uncontrollably as the father continues to pressure her into shouting her obedience. The episode closes with her trapped in this cycle of fear and physical pain, leaving the viewer to wonder if her forced compliance will actually stop the brothers from lying or keep the father from escalating his abuse further.